Gas measurement forms the basis of many important protocols, from biomethane potential testing to biodegradability analysis. By measuring how much gas is produced or consumed by something during a process, the material’s potential and process dynamics can be understood. Gas from a biological process can be measured using gasometric or manometric methods, but which system should you use, and what are the advantages and disadvantages of each?
3 min read
In short, manometric systems measure pressure changes in a closed bottle. They are simple to set up and suit short tests, often under seven days, but don’t meet most standards. Gasometric systems measure the volume of gas produced in an open set-up, so they can run for months and follow standard test protocols.
Measuring gas production or consumption can tell us a lot about a process, for example, understanding the biodegradability of a material. When exposed to environments, such as soil, microbes can begin to break down a material. How well they do this depends on many factors: what is the material made of? What type of microbes are present? How adapted are they to consuming this material in this environment? An overview of the process can easily be determined by looking at the different gases either produced or consumed during the biodegradation process.
The measurement of gas production or consumption is done with a piece of equipment called a respirometer. Respirometers may employ different methods of gas measurement, usually either manometric (pressure based) or gasometric (volume based). The most common gases to measure when looking at biological processes are oxygen (O2), carbon dioxide (CO2), methane (CH4), hydrogen (H2) and mixed gases.
| Manometric | Gasometric |
|---|---|
| Pressure based measurements | Volume based measurements |
| Closed system | Open system |
| Manometer | Gas volume measurement systems BPC’s respirometers |
| Simple to set up | More complex set-up |
| Short experiment time frame (< 7 days) – not compliant with standard protocols | “Unlimited” time frame, compliant with standard protocols |
Manometric systems, which rely on pressure measurements, tend to be operated as a closed system. The material to be tested is sealed in a reactor containing the desired testing environment, such as sea water or soil. Attached to the reactor is a manometer, which in the case of aerobic biodegradability studies, often contains an alkaline solution to absorb carbon dioxide (CO2) produced during biodegradation. During an aerobic biodegradation process, microbes produce CO2 while oxygen (O2) in the reactor headspace is consumed. This CO2 is in turn absorbed by the attached alkaline solution, lowering the overall pressure in the headspace. The pressure decrease is measured by the manometer, and can be used to calculate the total oxygen consumed.
While manometric methods are relatively simple to set-up, oxygen in the headspace will be depleted quickly. This means that the time frame for manometric experiments is very short, often less than 7 days, which does not comply with most testing standards. Furthermore, by calculating gas volume change from pressure changes, many assumptions need to be made.
On the other hand, gasometric methods often employ an open system, where produced gas can be released and a gas source drawn in. An aerobic test using gasometric measurement methods uses a similar principle to tests using manometric methods, but by measuring gas volume produced (or consumed), gives a more accurate and stable reading over time.
Furthermore, gasometric methods are not limited for timescale, and biodegradation tests can be conducted over months or even years using these systems. The main disadvantage of gasometric methods is the complexity of the systems, which generally require more man-power hours to operate.
BPC Instruments’ technology is based on gasometric methods, with one key difference from others – automated measurements. This allows for long-term, large-scale experiments to be performed without worry over human errors or significant man-power hours. A system such as BPC Blue Aerobic can conduct biodegradability tests over long periods of time with minimal intervention from the operator, leading not only to more data, but results that comply better with standard protocols.
Overall, both manometric and gasometric methods have advantages and disadvantages, but for automated testing, reliable long-term results and especially compliance with standard protocols, gasometric methods are highly recommended.

Book a 15 minute consultation
Discuss your testing needs with one of our product specialists and get guidance on the right instrument and setup for your laboratory.


